Spectrum of left - part 5 / Left in India - The historical blunders
The Price of Ideological Rigidity: A Critique of the Indian Left The history of the Indian Left is a record of consistent misalignment with the national pulse. For decades, the movement has allowed "High Doctrine" to trump practical reality, resulting in a series of strategic failures that have alienated them from the very masses they claim to represent. 1. The 1942 Betrayal and the Failure of M.N. Roy The roots of this alienation lie in the Quit India Movement of 1942. While the nation rose against British rule, the Left—following international directives from Moscow—chose to support the British war effort. By ignoring the pragmatic dissent of thinkers like M.N. Roy, who understood the local reality better than distant Comintern leaders, the Left branded itself as a movement that placed external orders above national aspirations. This was the first major instance of "opposing the British blindly" only when it served an international, rather than Indian, agenda. 2. ...